Two police officers in the United Kingdom have been dismissed for gross misconduct after they lied about conducting searches for missing persons whose bodies were later found in a crashed car in Cardiff, Wales, in 2023.
Police Constables Richard Hardwick and Lauren Livingstone were dismissed following a four-day misconduct hearing in Newport, where they were found guilty of dishonesty in their handling of the missing persons investigation.
The officers were accused of falsely claiming to have searched the homes of Eve Smith and Sophie Russon, two of the five occupants of a vehicle that crashed in St Mellons, Cardiff.
The car was discovered in a wooded area 46 hours after the accident, with three occupants dead and two others seriously injured.
The hearing established that Hardwick made false entries in official police records, claiming that searches had been conducted. He also gave dishonest accounts to his supervising officer and the Independent Office for Police Conduct.
Livingstone was similarly found to have made a false entry in the police log and misled her supervisor about the searches.
The chairman of the misconduct panel, Ian Arundale, said the officers had deliberately misled the missing persons investigation, potentially compromising its progress and damaging public confidence in the police.
He ruled that a final written warning was insufficient because of the seriousness of their misconduct and the harm caused.
Reacting to the verdict, Eve Smith’s mother, Emma Borg, said her family had been forced to revisit the most painful period of their lives while seeking answers about the police response.
She said the family had trusted the police to carry out their responsibilities but felt their honesty and credibility were questioned during the process.
“Instead, the dishonesty established during these proceedings undermined the missing persons’ investigation and the trust our families desperately needed to have in those responsible for helping us,” she added.
Smith’s sister, Lauren Doyle, described the officers’ dismissal as an important step towards accountability, saying the family remained determined to establish the full circumstances surrounding the incident.
She said, “Our search for answers continues. We will never lose sight of why we started.”
The three women, Smith, Russon and Darcy Ross, were reported missing to Gwent Police on March 4, 2023, after they failed to return from a night out the previous evening.
Five people were eventually discovered inside the crashed vehicle, including Rafel Jeanne and Shane Loughlin. Smith, Ross and Jeanne died, while Russon and Loughlin sustained serious injuries.
According to the IOPC, the officers failed to meet basic policing standards by not conducting the required property searches during the early stages of the investigation.
Derrick Campbell of the police watchdog described their conduct as a failure to “act honestly and with integrity”, stressing that property searches were a “basic but essential part in the early stages of a missing person investigation”.
He said: “PC Hardwick deliberately lied during the course of the missing person investigation, claiming on police records and to his supervisor that searches had been completed.
“PC Livingstone had ample opportunity to tell the IOPC the required searches had not been conducted.
“Instead, she did not give an account and stated she could not remember the specifics of her visits to the homes of two of the young women who had been reported missing,” Campbell said.