Former Germany international, Thomas Müller, has questioned the competitive structure of Major League Soccer, arguing that the absence of relegation creates less pressure on clubs and players compared with European leagues.
The Vancouver Whitecaps forward made the observations while reflecting on the differences between football in North America and Europe after completing his first full season in the United States and Canada.
Speaking in an interview with Global News, the 37-year-old said the MLS system makes it difficult to compare the competition with established European leagues, particularly because poorly performing teams do not face the threat of dropping into a lower division.
“It’s difficult to compare because of the competition system. Here, there is no relegation and there is not so much pressure. A team can say they are in a rebuilding process,” Müller said.
He explained that the consequences of relegation in Europe extend beyond sporting disappointment, as clubs risk losing revenue, while players and other employees could face uncertainty over their jobs.
“When a team gets relegated, they lose budget for the next season, and that affects the whole institution. Some people can even lose their jobs because of the financial changes. It’s also different for the fans and players, who could find themselves without a contract for the following season,” he added.
The former Bayern Munich star also suggested that the absence of relegation influences how teams approach matches, particularly those struggling towards the bottom of the table.
According to him, struggling European sides often approach games with greater urgency because their survival in the top division is at stake, a situation he believes is less pronounced in the MLS.
“Sometimes, I have the feeling that because of the MLS system, football here is a little bit more optimistic or carefree defensively,” he said, adding that the approach could also make matches more entertaining by creating attacking opportunities and open spaces.
Müller also identified inconsistency among players as another difference he had noticed between the MLS and European football.
He acknowledged that the American league has players capable of producing impressive individual performances but argued that maintaining the same standard throughout matches remains a challenge for some.
“When I compare both competitions, I see that in the MLS there are players who can produce individual moments of very high quality. However, something I sometimes miss is consistency. The difference between good and bad performances is bigger,” he said.
Using golf to explain his observation, Müller noted that even an amateur could occasionally produce a shot comparable to that of a professional, but the difference becomes obvious when consistency is considered.
He further stressed the importance of maintaining concentration throughout matches, saying some players needed to improve their attention and discipline over the full 90 minutes.
“I think sometimes what is missing is maintaining concentration and attention for the 90 minutes. That is something I have noticed in the MLS,” he added.
Müller joined Vancouver Whitecaps in August 2025 after spending 17 seasons with German giants Bayern Munich, where he won 13 Bundesliga titles and two UEFA Champions League trophies.
He was also part of Germany’s squad that won the 2014 FIFA World Cup in Brazil and scored 45 goals in 131 international appearances.
The attacking midfielder has continued his career in North America, helping Vancouver reach the 2025 MLS Cup final, where they lost 3-1 to Inter Miami.
His move to the MLS came after an illustrious career in European football, during which he made 756 appearances for Bayern, scoring 250 goals and providing numerous assists.
Despite his criticism of certain aspects of the competition, Müller has continued to commit his future to Vancouver, signing a contract extension in September that will keep him at the club through the 2027 MLS Sprint Season.